General Discussion

General DiscussionPosition 4 and Position 5

Position 4 and Position 5 in General Discussion
takodoro

    Is there any difference? I do not feel much difference between these 2 positions.

    < blank >

      Position 4 has 1 item and Position 5 have no items (not even boots)

      Dieser Kommentar wurde geändert
      Leelaw

        Position 4 usually supports that needs farm to get core items.

        Dieser Kommentar wurde geändert
        Miku Plays

          5 IS WARD BICH 4 IS CARRY SUPPORT

          Trodlabundin

            4 is 3,5
            5 is 6

            Now, you can try to understand.

            takodoro

              In terms of hero pool, which heroes are better suited for 4 and which are better suited for 5?

              Soultrap

                #5 - CM, Dazzle, Lich, Lion, Omni, Oracle, Rubick, SS, Sky, Venge, WD, WW.

                Everything else is #4.

                Dieser Kommentar wurde geändert
                takodoro

                  This is where the concept of position 4 and 5 start to have flaws. Lion, Rubick, SS definitely need that dagger to perform. Sure late game they can be #5, but early game they are more of #4.

                  Soultrap

                    That means nothing. Blink Dagger benefits all heroes.

                    TripleSteal-

                      you dont need blink to be relevant as ss, lion and rubick; you can do nice w/o it.

                      also, ww, ss, wd and cm are often played as pos 4 as well.

                      Yoshi

                        Don't go as pos 5 if you wanna get shiny items, it's much harder than pos 4.

                        Pilot

                          Position 4 is whatever support you would prefer to give farm priority to.

                          Riguma Borusu

                            Well, most pos5 supports CAN benefit from farm. CM can wreck teamfights with blink/aghs/glimmer/bkb, Lion can hit really hard with his ultimate with aghs+blink, etc. But the thing is, those heroes are not your CORE heroes for a reason. You have an idea why you've picked them, and placed tehm on position 5. It's because you want limited utility from them. You certainly can have position 2-3-4 lion if you want. But other heroes are going to do more things with that farm, so naturally, lion's gonna take a dive, unless there's an obvious position 5 hero in your team, like AA, for example. There have been a plenty of position 2 shadow shamans and lions in DotA's past, but people have then realized that those heroes can do most of their thing without taking much farm from heroes that scale better with it.

                            Dieser Kommentar wurde geändert
                            Totentanz to The King: M ...

                              It's about hero duos more than single heroes. The less greedy one is usually 5.

                              Crudude

                                In my pubs I find there is no real difference
                                There is either one position 5 (and no 4) or two position 4s lol

                                Dieser Kommentar wurde geändert
                                Riguma Borusu

                                  You can't play pos5 support at lower levels simply because you will have no impact in the game. Being greedy will help you do something, and this is unfortunate, for example, in Normal Skill. Their supports will share EXP with their carries, so your impact will be limited because you are level 4 when their support in lane is level 6, but your carry is level 8 and theirs 6, but you can't use that advantage because there's little coordination to be had, and people usually do not quite understand what advantage they have if they let carry have solo exp for some time.

                                  So in low level pubs, there's literally no 1-5 system, you have safelane carry, mid carry, offlane carry, then maybe one more carry that splits lane farm with someone or jungles, and one support if you are lucky.

                                  TripleSteal-

                                    correct warding has a lot of impact at any level

                                    Dieser Kommentar wurde geändert
                                    Lleaff

                                      Pos 5 is selfless, Pos 4 is greedy. The best way to keep up as a 5 role I've found is to buy a smoke with your wards and gather someone strong + your greedy support and gank at the same time as warding. That way your warding time is spent getting your team a vision advantage as well as gaining yourself and two other XP. Or it fails and gg but that's dota.

                                      lm ao

                                        Guys, when I play supports for my stack, I usually pick really aggresive ones like AA, CM, etc. What do you call me?

                                        Riguma Borusu

                                          "correct warding has a lot of impact at any level"

                                          Provided people look on the minimap, I guess.

                                          BenaoLifedancer

                                            before asking you should learn WHAT THEY FUCKING ARE YOU FUCKING RUSSIAN STUPID MONKEY

                                            lm ao

                                              OMG ^

                                              even though you are such a serious nut

                                              lm ao

                                                +1 to sven

                                                BenaoLifedancer

                                                  ayy lmao :p ^
                                                  serious face on

                                                  Relentless

                                                    Some support heroes need a core item to function well mid-game. Some don't. If you have one that does need something like a blink mid-game it helps to have a 5 position support take the majority of the warding so the 4 can accumulate enough gold for the blink/fstaff/glimmer cape or whatever. If they split the gold equally neither will get that item in time.

                                                    Miku Plays

                                                      if carry cant farm u fail as 5, better if ur carry

                                                      lm ao

                                                        Benao I was referring to sven, I didnt expect you would also comment here as well

                                                        Ofc Benao is numbah 1 in mah heart 3h3h3h3

                                                        BenaoLifedancer

                                                          <3<3<3

                                                          TuSugar

                                                            I think it depends on enemy heroes to determinate which heroes gonna be 4 or 5, if you can make good team fight securing the Witch doctor's life, he must be your 4, rush Agha and make a strongest damage to the enemy team. Other example, maybe for pubs. If the enemy team get a lot of Str Heroes or a lot of armor heroes, you want to be a 4 Dazzle and no a 5, Rush (again) Aghamin and make a -40 Armor to help your teammates more than only placing wards. It depends on the game more than heroes.

                                                            BenaoLifedancer

                                                              Preyy sure i posted this "<3<3<3" ...

                                                              BenaoLifedancer

                                                                ohhh " <3 " testing again

                                                                TripleSteal-

                                                                  dazzle rushing aghs sounds like a bullshit to me
                                                                  get medallion into solar instead and dont spend 4200 on a relatively useless item

                                                                  BenaoLifedancer

                                                                    We can't post "<" and "3" together

                                                                    BenaoLifedancer

                                                                      OMFG! (<) IS BANNED HER OR WHAT

                                                                      BenaoLifedancer

                                                                        gg i give up with " ( < ) " ?

                                                                        TripleSteal-

                                                                          "

                                                                          BenaoLifedancer

                                                                            dazzle should be first pick in competitive, TOP pick. Pros are just too slow to realize!

                                                                            BenaoLifedancer

                                                                              This "^" horizontally can't be posted

                                                                              Crudude

                                                                                Nooooo hopefully the pros never realise that
                                                                                I am loving playing with Dazzle and don't want Dazzle to be pub infested :(

                                                                                Dire Wolf

                                                                                  The difference is just who buys wards. 5s are expected to buy all wards until 4 has like one item. Like if you are playing shadow shaman and cm, cm is probably buying all the wards while shaman gets aghs, then switch so cm can get item. In pubs anyway where there is no 3 spot, just 3 carries, 2 supports.