General Discussion

General DiscussionIs Undying a candidate to be nerfed?

Is Undying a candidate to be nerfed? in General Discussion
Ariel Winter

    Personally, I disagree with the assumption that he's op in this meta. Thoughts? Post your rationales pls

    Last picking is 4 pussies

      Tbh if you play unranked it's becoming a theme for parties to do a quick undying/gyro pick kind of annoying.

      Lyra

        I see no reason to nerf just because he got more populare. Still easy to counter in many ways.

        matrice

          zombies are too strong right now

          Russian National Team Coach

            64% winrate in VHS ranked. He is even higher than 6.82a Spectre levels, so yeah definately gonna get nerfed. It's kinda like when Centaur got into Dota2.

            Dieser Kommentar wurde geändert
            Bad Intentions

              with the right early game lineup, undying is pretty much unstoppable.

              Mandalorian

                "zombies are too strong right now"

                This.

                TripleSteal-

                  he definetely will get nerfed

                  Pom Pom 🍕

                    it's nice that they made him not useless against a lot of heroes, but creeps and towers counting as a half hit on zombies as well is a little too much. When removing a way a hero is countered they should give him a nerf in the pack as well.

                    Totentanz to The King: M ...

                      He wins lanes and pushes, but that's about all he does. He can't gank, can't scale well at all, decay costs too much and ulti is just a disgrace to ultis I think. Also I don't understand all the fuzz about him suddenly becoming OP. Zombies don't die to physical spells now so what? Most of the time you didn't even lane against heroes that kill them with spells. But his pickrate is still pretty low for such a high winrate hero so you can say he is only played in very high skill games.

                      Kryptnyt

                        "Most of the time you didn't even lane against heroes that kill them with spells."
                        Still annoying when a Bristleback can just passively kill all of your zombies or gargoyles with his quills. When people realize that Bristleback is no longer a hard counter to Undying his winrate might taper off a bit.

                        TripleSteal-

                          @sam
                          actually your first sentence is the only point that matters in current meta. early-game and mid-game pushes/kills decide the game's result now, and since undying is particularly strong in these, he gets his incredible winrate. either meta will change or undying gets his nerf.

                          Dieser Kommentar wurde geändert
                          TripleSteal-

                            undying is not OP, just this patch's tendencies highlighted his strentgh, and his weaknesses no longer matter this much. Not the undying, but his surrounding changed.
                            At least as far as I see it.

                            Dieser Kommentar wurde geändert
                            Pom Pom 🍕

                              it's not only that Axe, bristle, tide, etc can't instakill all zombies anymore, but the zombie don't instantly die to creeps either or even the towers because of the 2 non-hero hit needed. (Sniper and troll were really strong against him too, but got nerfed a lot, so in pubs at least his winrate is huge because of those heroes having way lower wr).

                              The meta also didn't favour him last patch that much since most games went too late for him, but now with squishier t3s and t2s it's easier to end fast while he's still relevant.

                              Dieser Kommentar wurde geändert
                              Lyra

                                OK, since you say he is to strong right now.

                                Then tell me how do you do in order to counter him? What picks? What lanes? What items? What game strategy?

                                Troll, Bristle and Gyro is a few examples of heroes that counter him badly before. I dont see why it would not work anymore.

                                BenaoLifedancer

                                  in rankeds i just ignore him but ive lost a couple against him... the reason is more my teammates though so idc... its just annoying to play against it, especially when the fuckers dual or trilane offlane him to my safelane with woods support gg

                                  Mandalorian

                                    Just dont go trilanes vs him or you'll get raped if the guy playing it is a descent player. If you let him get lvl 3 fast, you pretty much lost the lane and gave him double-tripple kill and you cant come back to it anymore or you'll feed even more. The only way to play vs this hero is to get AM and let him solo the lane, max mana burn and then he's just food. Also extremely well organized nuker trilanes can destroy him, but you wont see a lot of them in the pubs.

                                    All in all, it's really annoying hero to play against, especially if the players knows his hero well.

                                    BenaoLifedancer

                                      last game i lost to zombie i think, i had a necro afk ancients that went for midas (reddit shit) and sk woods (20 min dagger uncontested) ez loss!!!!!! while i had to play against a trilane. And i got lp right after the game, best shit ever! needless to say even with this trash mmr i have right now, it was the highest....

                                      Crudude

                                        I think undyings ulti can be insane actually, especially when combined with another ulti. Adding 40 % odd extra damage to wds ult is incredible...

                                        In my opinion though, He is so easily countered unless you have a team that really suits him
                                        I don't understand how he has over 60 % win rate..

                                        Pom Pom 🍕

                                          The shame about undy's ulti is that elder titan's aura (a basic ability) can often do just as much or more bonus damage, as it's way easier to keep on your enemies thanks to his spirit that can be cast from range. His tombstone is a lot more insane than his ultimate (until late game of course).

                                          #12

                                            I wonder if his win rate will go down when people get better at dealing with him?

                                            is gyro a good counter now?
                                            does axe still counter him, his spins don't kill zombies, but then again more zombies = more spins.
                                            do you just all focus the tomb stone as 5 for a second to kill it fast, or do you ignore it, or do you just back off like cow heard when tomb stone is down.

                                            do zombies count for eco slam. if they do? do you pick shaker and brood and make 100 zombies fight 20 spiders, then slam when tomb gets dropped?

                                            EmptyJar

                                              Kill tomb?

                                              Totentanz to The King: M ...

                                                Just don't feed him kills and you will be fine. He is a terrible farmer and if he can't get items he can easily get focused down.

                                                Dieser Kommentar wurde geändert
                                                Im the Bully of my School

                                                  HAAARRR ! FFFLLLLLLGRRRR HHAAAARR HARRR !! GRAAAAAAAAAAA!! BLUUUPPPPPGRRAAAA!GBRAHHA BJHRHAAAARRRRRRRRRRR AAAAAAAAAAAARRRRRRRGGGGGGGGGGG !! FLAARRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR!

                                                  SalaciousCrome

                                                    Honestly I think he takes advantage of stupidity in players. I have had a couple bad games where people knew what they were doing and would stand still hitting the tombstone leaving me out in the open with nothing but decay to keep me up. Kill the tombstone, don't run and undying becomes pretty average.

                                                    eXcel

                                                      Yeah, but also with soul rip sometimes that tombstone doesn´t go down so easy! I had it happen in my last game http://www.dotabuff.com/matches/1452956680

                                                      The team focused the tombstone a few times so I just soul-ripped it back up to health and they still died.

                                                      гриндр

                                                        One of the most broken heroes in Dota's history. Sniper & Troll were balanced compared to current Undying.

                                                        eXcel

                                                          He just wins early team fights and this patch is geared to that. Also the zombie buff makes things easier.

                                                          ΙγrιΙΙνεmροs crιsτεναηιsh...

                                                            shit hero,all who pick it=fag

                                                            mwsqz

                                                              i heard ta is good vs tumb

                                                              narsnail

                                                                Lane with Dazzle/Undying. Very frustrating.

                                                                npc
                                                                  Dieser Kommentar wurde von einem Moderator entfernt
                                                                  Mekarazium
                                                                    Dieser Kommentar wurde von einem Moderator entfernt
                                                                    BoBy-Ro

                                                                      Definetely not op, just overrated. I would say Zeus/Lina are more op than Undying.

                                                                      Dieser Kommentar wurde geändert
                                                                      Treckster

                                                                        http://www.dotabuff.com/players/88208/matches?date=patch_6.84&hero=undying&skill_bracket=&lobby_type=&game_mode=&region=&faction=&duration=&enjoyment=any

                                                                        looks broken to me ^^

                                                                        edit: but you need to yell at your teammates that they have to push like retarded.. otherwise they go jungling and shit

                                                                        Dieser Kommentar wurde geändert
                                                                        casual gamer

                                                                          not op in pubs where you can pick gyrocopter

                                                                          casual gamer

                                                                            lina and ursa should legit just be removed from dota

                                                                            Low Expectations

                                                                              Ironically he has become a good counter to Bristle because he now has to turn and kill the zombies rather than just run away spamming W. He needs a small nerf but def. not super OP

                                                                              Trodlabundin

                                                                                Just pick Gyro, dodge his lane and just win dota2. Pretty simple.

                                                                                Go Gyro offlane, with +1 unless you're 1v1 where gyro beats most heroes offlane

                                                                                Luxon

                                                                                  He just wins games in 20 minutes, nothing special guys.
                                                                                  TBH he was already very strong before but 6.84 just removed all direct counters to him. He is getting picked more and more all the time (already #1 in VH ranked) and soon everyone will feel the plague.

                                                                                  Low Expectations

                                                                                    ^Really most picked in VH? I feel like zeus is more popular than Undying

                                                                                    [Lk].Zano

                                                                                      ^ #1 in winrate, not popularity.

                                                                                      Luxon
                                                                                        Dieser Kommentar wurde geändert
                                                                                        [Lk].Zano

                                                                                          ^ Dayum

                                                                                          Luxalpa, Primal Calamity

                                                                                            Hero has been #2 winrate last patch and got buffed, of course it is OP. Tombstone is extremely broken, undying is invulnerable for the first 20 minutes of the game.

                                                                                            That being said, people need to adapt and they start doing it. Having a dual lane or a trilane against Undying is asking to lose.

                                                                                            With a solo lane it is manageable.

                                                                                            Dieser Kommentar wurde geändert
                                                                                            Last picking is 4 pussies

                                                                                              ^---most the games I see undying it is never him alone.

                                                                                              Always a dual lane or aggressive tri lane.

                                                                                              [Lk].Zano

                                                                                                Now that I think about it. Any discussion about the hero is kind of pointless. "IS UNDYING A CANDIDATE TO BE NERFED?" is the question of the topic and we all know what happens when one hits the forbidden 60 number. OP or not :P

                                                                                                Let's see how long it will take, I actually really enjoyed playing Undying before this patch and it's feeling a bit dirty picking him, even if it's just in my friends' lobbys.

                                                                                                THICC BABY SHUM

                                                                                                  the most op hero was super old lycan that jungled up like 4 min vlads and fast necro book and win games

                                                                                                  casual gamer

                                                                                                    i think ghost scepter huskar was maybe more op, but its debatable